Order Issued in Greer v Advantage Health by Supreme Court

The Supreme Court has issued an Order in Greer v Advantage Health reversing its previous grant of leave. In Greer, the Court of Appeals held that a plaintiff could recover economic damages in the amount billed by the health care provider, without reducing that amount to (i) what was actually paid by the patient or insurer or (ii) the amount of an asserted lien. This results in a windfall to plaintiffs. The Supreme Court initially granted leave and even held oral argument. But the Order reversing leave means the Court will not consider the issue at this time. The result is that the Court of Appeals’ Opinion currently stands. Three justices wrote separately to advise the Legislature that the statute should be amended to remedy the windfall issue.

Importantly, though, the procedural posture of Greer may have caused the Supreme Court to decide that the case was not the best one for it to issue a rule of law.  It is possible that the Court will consider the issue in the future if a case with a different procedural posture is presented for its review.

If you would like a copy of the opinion or would like to discuss further, please contact Stephanie Hoffer at shoffer@shrr.com or 616.458.6458.

Download PDF.